Social Sundays: Supporting the Research Paper

A professor of mine in college used to say "it's harder to write a great 5-page paper than to write a terrible 10-page paper."  Her point was that it's better to make a clear argument in less words than to be unclear in many.

As an academic I'm someone who writes "short."  Others write long. I find long writing a bit overwhelming.  Sometimes, I wonder that I finished a dissertation and a book.


I remember as a student being completely daunted when I was assigned my first 500-word essay.  How could I possibly fill that much space?  And although, I don't still have that paper, I suspect that it was not very good, for rather than work on a good argument, my focus was on getting that all important word count.



As a teacher, even though I don't give specific word counts or page lengths, I find that many of my students struggle as well with research papers. Often students have all the ideas, but don't know how to organize these ideas. Sometimes, students are overwhelmed by the more in-depth format expected in secondary classrooms.


After reading some beautifully crafted papers and several that demonstrated an incredible struggle on my students' part, I created a student guidebook to writing a research paper.  As a social studies teacher, my focus tends not to be on the how-to of writing, but I reasoned that students could benefit from a little support, and I would benefit by reading better crafted papers.

When students are writing research essays, I print a guidebook for each student and hole punch it so that the students can keep the guide in their binders. It could just as easilyy be glued into notebooks. The guidebook walks students through the process of writing a paper:




- students brainstorm about what they know and want to know
students select a few areas about the topic that are connected
students conduct research and track their sources as they go
students organize their ideas
students make an argument and support it with evidence
students put it all together
students revise and edit (and have a guide that shows the difference)
students write drafts

I don't spend any time teaching this directly, but with the handbook as a guide and in class time to work, student writing is improving. I've been surprised by the many thanks that I have received from students for the guide. As one girl put it "I feel like I can make sense of all my ideas, and I'm not just buried in facts that I don't know what to do with." (You can get a guidebook for your students here.)

This is all to say that in taking time to put together the guide for my students and work with them on it, I am reminded of the role we all play in supporting life long student learning. It isn't enough for students to understand the content, which I admit I get awfully excited about, but also students are developing skills to communicate their knowledge.  It's not only okay to slow down on content but also essential to spend time on developing important life tools.





Social Sundays is a bi-weekly post sharing tips, ideas, resources, and products for teaching social studies.  If you have questions or think there is something I should share, you can leave me a message in the comments below or at the store in the question and answer section.  

Share:

2 comments

  1. One of my least favorite questions from students is, "how long does it have to be" and my response is always along the lines of "however long it takes you to make your point." Your guide to writing a research paper looks like a great resource!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So true! I love your response. Just like I am not a fan of the "how do I get an A?" So far the resource is working well. I am sure it will go through some revisions as more students test it out, but that is the beauty of teacher resource places...you get every revision for free.

      Delete